What about the Supremacy Clause?
It says the Constitution, and the laws of the United States made in pursuance of it, shall be the supreme law of the land. Roe and Hodes & Nauser were not made in pursuance of the Constitution. They conflict with its equality clauses, so they are not the supreme law of the land. States are not bound by those unlawful court decisions.
Would abolition bills put abortive mothers in jail?
An abolition bill criminalizes the act of abortion, not a list of people. It removes prenatal homicide exceptions so the laws that protect people after birth protect people before birth. It is up to the justice system to determine whether a man or a woman was a principal in prenatal murder.
Will an abolition bill punish people for abortions in the past?
No. The Constitution prohibits ex post facto laws. The bill is not retroactive. It does not apply to abortions before the effective date, to natural miscarriages, to emergency treatment aimed at saving the mother while taking available steps to save the child, or to persons subject to mistake of fact.
Do abolition bills promote lawlessness?
No. Lawlessness is the situation we have now. John Adams called for a government of laws and not of men. An abolition bill is a return to the Constitution and an end to following an opinion of men that violates it. The law is king. The court is subject to that law, not master of it.
If abortion is murder, will people who pressure women face prosecution?
Treating abortion as murder is one of the best ways to protect women in peril. An investigation can uncover trafficking, a pimp, or an abusive partner conspiring to commit prenatal murder. While abortion is legal for the woman, there is no investigation and no pressure that can surface the real conspirator. Exemption laws become a shield for abusers.
What is wrong with incrementalism?
Nineteenth-century abolitionists taught that gradualism prolonged slavery. The Liberator wrote in 1857 of a process “half way between now and never.” William Wilberforce wrote that the gradual abolitionists were the real stay of the slave trade they claimed to oppose.
Has incrementalism prolonged the abortion industry?
The new frontier is medication abortion. The Guttmacher Institute reported that 63% of abortions in 2023 were by pill. Pro-life laws have closed some surgical clinics and have not kept up. A Foundation to Abolish Abortion report found 83,794 telehealth abortions in “ban” states in 2024, not counting pills ordered from places such as Aid Access. It has never been easier to murder a prenatal child.
Aren’t more states abortion-free since Dobbs?
There is no abortion-free state. Every state allows surgical abortion in some circumstances and self-managed abortion in practice. Eleven states have passed constitutional amendments that explicitly allow abortion. Before Dobbs, no state constitution had enshrined abortion. For prenatal humans, justice is in a worse place than it was during Roe.
What is your duty as a civil magistrate?
“Justice, and only justice, shall you pursue” (Deut. 16:20). Establish justice in the courts (Amos 5:15). Rescue those being led away to death (Prov. 24:11). Correct oppression and bring justice to the fatherless (Isaiah 1:17). There is no one more fatherless than a child delivered over to death by abortion. It is time to obey God and the Constitution and totally abolish abortion.